Bio

<aside> 💡 Mel Andrews is a philosopher of science and technology investigating the human use and misuse of mathematical and computational tools in science and societal decision-making. Mel earned a doctorate in philosophy in 2025 from the University of Cincinnati with a thesis titled ‘The Math & the Territory: On the Scientific Uses & Abuses of Machine Learning & Other Mathematical Modelling Strategies.’ Currently, Mel is a postdoctoral research associate jointly affiliated with the Center for Information Technology Policy (CITP) at Princeton University and the Natural and Artificial Minds Initiative (NAM) of the Princeton AI Lab. Mel’s also the principal investigator on a grant from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation’s Metascience and AI funding scheme assessing the epistemic credentials of AI in science evaluation.

</aside>

Screenshot 2026-04-22 at 8.17.45 pm.png

“This is what is happening when we try to take theories and models from the cognitive sciences and apply them to software systems.”

“These concepts [“love”, “sadness, “Consciousness” and “Understanding”], importantly, cannot be properly operationalised wholesale. There is no definitive scientific test of whether or not ‘my cat loves me,’ or whether or not ‘trees can think.’”

“For all of the above reasons, I do not think we are likely to ever see properly scientific and non-question-begging research into the question of whether or not language models “understand” language (or anything, for that matter).”

The Math & the Territory: On the Scientific Uses & Abuses of Machine Learning & Other Mathematical Modeling Strategies

etd.ohiolink.edu